Protecting Groundwater Quality: The Spring Creek Watershed Drilling Ordinance Success Story
By Todd Giddings, Ph.D., P.G., Chairman of the Spring Creek Watershed Commission’s Construction Standards Workgroup
Pennsylvania has no statewide regulations for the proper construction of geothermal heat pump system boreholes or residential water wells. The 120,000+ residents who live in the 175 square-mile Spring Creek Watershed in Centre County are 99.99% dependent on groundwater and use more than 16 million gallons per day. Geothermal boreholes were being filled with sand or pea gravel that would allow contaminants to enter the limestone aquifers. Most of the casings on the few new water-wells that were being drilled were not being grouted into the limestone bedrock. These improper construction methods for the many new geothermal boreholes and the few new water wells were threatening the quality of the groundwater in the Spring Creek Watershed.
Before the construction standards ordinance was in place, sand from the pile was the only material used to backfill the 36 geothermal boreholes in this commercial building loop field. The coils of pipe are the ends of the loops in each borehole. The sand provided a direct short-circuit flow pathway in each borehole for contaminats to reach the water table.
So in June, 2009, the Centre County League of Women Voters held a Public Forum where the threats to the groundwater quality were presented and discussed. The citizens and municipal officials who attended this Public Forum called for the development of watershed-wide construction standards for both water-supply wells and for geothermal boreholes. In response, the Spring Creek Watershed Commission (composed of representatives from each municipality in the watershed) created a construction standards workgroup that drafted the new construction standards for both water-supply wells and for geothermal boreholes.
The State College Borough and the five surrounding townships have a central Building Code Enforcement Agency that operates within a Council of Governments. The new water-well and geothermal borehole construction standards were implemented in Chapter 10 within the Building Safety & Property Maintenance Code in 2010. Code inspection personnel and local drilling companies attended training sessions where the details of the new construction standards were presented. By using the Building Code Chapter to implement the new construction standards, it took less than one year to have the new standards in place. This is certainly a record short time for such far-reaching environmental protection standards to be requested, created, and then enacted.
The grouting requirements for the geothermal boreholes in this commercial loop field project at an
elementary school were modified by a contract change order to bring them into compliance with the new construction standards that were implemented after this project was bid.
The new construction standards require that any borehole more than 20 feet deep be permitted. The PGWA 2013 Summer Field Conference demonstration borehole will be drilled to a depth of approximately 50 feet, and hence will require a permit. Borehole permits cost $150 for 1 to 5 boreholes, and additional boreholes have a $75 fee for groups of 5 boreholes.
At the end of the mud-rotary drilling demonstration, the PGWA 2013 Summer Field Conference demonstration borehole will be decommissioned with a bentonite grout emplaced by the pressure-tremie-pipe method to meets the construction standards. The 6-inch steel casing is going to be removed as the borehole is grouted up to the ground surface.
The implementation of the new water-well and geothermal borehole construction standards was accomplished in other municipalities outside the Council of Governments through individual municipal ordinances. The protection of the groundwater quality throughout the Spring Creek Watershed by implementing construction standards for both water-wells and for geothermal boreholes is a success story that can be repeated at a statewide level. House Bill 1855 was introduced in December of 2011, and is now House Bill 343. The Pennsylvania Ground Water Association and the Pennsylvania Council of Professional Geologists have both supported and contributed to this new proposed legislation. The full text of House Bill 343 is available at this link. This is a test link.